MCLC: Wukan revolt

[Denton, Kirk]

MCLC LIST
From: kirk (denton.2 at osu.edu)
Subject: Wukan revolt
***********************************************************

The article is accompanied by a video and a slideshow.

Kirk

==========================================================

Source: Wall Street Journal
(12/15/11):http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424052970203518404577097532
246936046.html

Land Dispute in China Town Sparks Revolt
Guangdong Standoff Underlines Anger
By JEREMY PAGE in Beijing and BRIAN SPEGELE in Lufeng County, China

A fishing village of about 20,000 people in southern China is in open
revolt against the local government a day after it announced the death in
police custody of a villager who had led protests over an alleged land
grab, according to residents.

Villagers say the man was murdered, but police say he died of a heart
attack.

The villagers have forced local officials and police to flee Wukan in the
southern province of Guangdong‹China's export powerhouse‹and have erected
barricades to prevent them from re-entering, according to residents.

The police have responded by imposing a blockade on Wukan, stopping food
and water from entering, and preventing local fishing boats from heading
out to sea, the residents said.

Outside Wukan, life appeared normal with shops and markets open. Police
erected a roadblock three or four miles from Wukan and checked cars
traveling in both directions. They prevented a Wall Street Journal
reporter from entering.

A press officer for the local government denied that any land grab had
occurred, although he did acknowledge that villagers were angry over a
land issue. He said the local government understood local concerns, and
the situation would be resolved either this week or next.

"It will absolutely have a smooth resolution," the official said.

The siege in the prosperous province is one of the most serious recent
examples of mass unrest in China, much of it due to local officials
misappropriating farmland and selling it to property developers at an
enormous profit that farmers never see.

Illegal land seizures‹often for golf courses, luxury villas and hotels‹are
seen by many Chinese and foreign experts as the single biggest threat to
the Communist Party as it struggles to maintain legitimacy in a society
that is becoming increasingly demanding and well-informed, thanks in large
measure to the Internet, even as income disparities widen.

Such land disputes account for 65% of "mass incidents"‹the government's
euphemism for large protests‹in rural areas, according to Yu Jianrong, a
professor and expert on rural issues at the state-run Chinese Academy of
Social Sciences.
Mr. Yu estimates that local officials have seized about 16.6 million acres
of rural land (more than the entire state of West Virginia) since 1990,
depriving farmers of about two trillion yuan ($314 billion) due to the
discrepancy between the compensation they receive and the land's real
market value.

China's Land Ministry has also warned that misappropriation of farmland
has brought the country dangerously close to the so-called red line of 296
million acres of arable land that the government believes it needs to feed
China's 1.34 billion people.

The Land Ministry, which uses satellite imagery to spot abuses, launched a
fresh crackdown on illegal land use this year, targeting golf courses,
hotels and villas in particular, and has announced several high-profile
cases in which officials have been punished.

But the central government's attempts to curb such abuses, and to draft
new legislation that would protect against land grabs and give farmers a
market rate for their land, have met fierce resistance from local
authorities who rely on land sales to maintain growth, service debt and
top up their budgets.

In 2010 alone, China's local governments raised 2.9 trillion yuan from
land sales. And the National Audit Office estimates that 23% of local
government debt, which it put at 10.7 trillion yuan in June, depends on
land sales for repayment.

In Wukan, Chinese authorities now face a tough choice between sending in
more security forces to restore order‹and risking serious violence‹or
negotiating a compromise with the villagers and possibly encouraging
copycat protests across the country.

The standoff is particularly risky for Wang Yang, the Communist Party
chief of Guangdong, who is vying with other candidates for promotion to
the Politburo Standing Committee‹the party's top decision-making body‹in a
once-a-decade leadership change next year.

Mr. Wang launched a "Happy Guangdong" campaign this year, pledging to
focus on improving living standards while slowing GDP growth in the
province of 104 million people that pioneered China's economic reforms and
has long been seen as a bellwether of the country's future.

Mr. Wang's campaign has been undermined by a series of high-profile labor
and land disputes this year, including riots by hundreds of migrant
workers in the cities of Zengcheng and Chaozhou. The rioters attacked
government offices and overturned police cars over several days in June.

In China, all urban land is owned by the state, although usage rights can
be traded. Farmland belongs to rural collectives, headed by village
officials, and usage rights can also be traded, though only for
agriculture.

Under Chinese law, local governments can acquire farmland for construction
projects that are "in the public interest" in exchange for compensation
based on a multiple of the land's agricultural yield, rather than its
market value.

In reality, local authorities often hatch those deals secretly with
village officials, change the land's status from rural to urban to allow
construction, and then sell the land-use rights to property developers at
an enormous profit, according to experts in the field.

In such cases, some villagers are typically angered that rights to their
land have been sold at all, while others are upset that they are not paid
the market value, with most of the profits going to the officials and
developers.

"This kind of dispute is very widespread," said Eva Pils, an associate
professor of law specializing in land disputes in China at the Chinese
University of Hong Kong.

"Because people are better connected and better informed, you can sense
that there is more radical opposition to what's happening to them," she
said. "It's also easier for this kind of protest to spread‹and far harder
to isolate because information can still travel."

The unrest in Wukan began in September, when villagers attacked local
government offices to protest against officials who they said had sold the
rights for their land to property developers without providing proper
compensation.

Some villagers have said that local officials sold the land to a property
developer for as much as one billion yuan and then pocketed about 70% of
that.

Local authorities responded at first by sending in riot police, but later
tried to negotiate with villagers, asking them to appoint 13
representatives to deal with the government. Those negotiations failed to
achieve a compromise, however, and last week men in plainclothes detained
some of the 13 representatives, villagers say.

On Tuesday, the local government announced that one of the detained
representatives, 42-year-old Xue Jinbo, had died of a cardiac arrest in
custody Sunday.

Mr. Xue's relatives believe he was beaten to death, according to
villagers. "We lament his death, as he died for us," one villager, who
asked to be identified only by his surname, Lin, said in a telephone
interview.

He said that Mr. Xue's mother, wife and elder brother had been to see his
corpse and had found three fractures, as well as several scars.

China's state-run Xinhua news agency published a report Wednesday quoting
a local prosecutor denying that there were any signs of assault on Mr.
Xue's body.

Xinhua said Mr. Xue was suspected of having led protests in Wukan in
September "regarding issues related to land use, financing and the
election of local officials." It said he and other villagers had broken
into local government offices and police stations and destroyed six police
cars.

Mr. Xue and two others were arrested Friday on suspicion of damaging
public property and disrupting public service, it said, quoting a local
police official.

He pleaded guilty to the accusations during two interrogations on Friday
and Saturday, Xinhua quoted the police official as saying.

A fellow inmate reported that Mr. Xue was ill Sunday, Xinhua quoted the
police as saying, and he was immediately taken to a nearby hospital, where
he died after 30 minutes of emergency treatment.

The official added that Mr. Xue had a history of asthma and heart disease,
according to Xinhua.

A report issued by the forensic medicine center at Zhongshan University in
the nearby city of Guangzhou said no serious wounds were found on the body
except for a few bruises on his wrists and knees, Xinhua said.

"We assume handcuffs left the marks on his wrists, and his knees were
bruised slightly when he knelt," it quoted Luo Bin, deputy chief of the
center, as saying.

The escalation of the protest was reported this week by the Daily
Telegraph newspaper.

‹Kersten Zhang and Olivia Geng in Beijing contributed to this article.