MCLC: Kashgar remodeled

[Denton, Kirk]

MCLC LIST
From: kirk (denton.2 at osu.edu)
Subject: Kashgar remodeled
***********************************************************

Source: NYT (3/5/14):
http://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/06/world/asia/china-remodels-an-ancient-silk
-road-city-and-an-ethnic-rift-widens.html

China Remodels an Ancient Silk Road City, and an Ethnic Rift Widens
By DAN LEVIN

KASHGAR, China — Visitors walking through the mud-brick rubble and yawning
craters where close-packed houses and bazaars once stood could be forgiven
for thinking that the ancient Silk Road city of Kashgar had been
irrevocably lost to the wrecking ball. A billboard looming over the ruins
tries to counter that impression: “Inherit and preserve the historical
culture to showcase a brand new Kashgar.”

The Chinese authorities set out five years ago to modernize Kashgar’s
fabled Old City district while promising to preserve its dense Casbah-like
charms. But the results underscore the growing divide between the
government and the ethnic minority that lives here — the Uighurs, a
Muslim, Turkic-speaking people who have chafed at Beijing’s rule since
Communist troops took over their traditional homeland in 1949. The region,
in China’s far west, is now known as Xinjiang, a Mandarin term meaning
“new frontier.”

The official narrative of the modernization project justified tearing down
65,000 homes and resettling 220,000 Uighur residents as crucial to
improving their lives. “Houses in the Old City of Kashgar are mostly old
and dilapidated, extremely vulnerable to earthquakes and fire,” said a
2010 report by Xinhua, the state news agency, that was widely republished
in the Chinese government-controlled media. “The renovation of the Old
City zone in Kashgar is a project that complied with the wishes of the
people,” the report claimed.

But propaganda slogans posted across the Old City, like “Everyone has the
responsibility to create peace and security,” hint at political tremors in
Xinjiang that are much more worrying to the Chinese government than any
natural disaster. Uighurs have protested discrimination, restrictive
religious policies and suppression of Uighur-language education as people
from the Han majority have settled in Xinjiang by the millions.

The tensions have spilled over into increasingly violent clashes.

On Saturday, violence spread to a railway station in a distant southwest
Chinese city, Kunming, where a group of knife-wielding assailants killed
at least 29 people and wounded 143. The Chinese authorities described the
mass slaughter as a “premeditated, violent terrorist attack” perpetrated
by separatists from Xinjiang.

For many Uighurs, the demolition of Kashgar’s Old City is a physical
symbol of the Chinese government’s efforts to destroy their cultural
identity. More than two-thirds of the centuries-old houses there have been
razed and replaced with new buildings made to look old and equipped with
central heating, indoor plumbing and electricity. The government pays for
building a new house’s first floor; residents must pay for everything else.

Some residents are pleased. “Even though the neighborhood has changed,
we’re much happier with our new house,” said a dressmaker who identified
herself only as Ayesha, standing in her new kitchen. Though none of the
arabesque filigree details of her family’s 500-year-old residence were
preserved, she said, her family incorporated traditional design elements
into the new doors and windows. “It’s a lot safer,” she added.

But many of the former residents could not afford what is essentially
gentrification by government fiat, and they have not returned to the
neighborhood.

The Uighurs who have come back tend to be the wealthier ones, government
employees and successful merchants whose economic well-being depends on
their cooperation with the Han-dominated authorities.

The rest have been scattered to drab apartment blocks on the city’s
outskirts, far from their traditional way of life. Local officials
silenced any complaints and introduced a so-called zero-tolerance system
to keep residents from airing their grievances to higher authorities.

Out of earshot of the tour guides and police minders who invariably follow
visiting foreign reporters, some Uighurs say the government has shown
little interest in preserving the city’s architectural heritage.

At the end of a dusty alley, an aging Uighur woman eagerly welcomed
visitors into her 300-year-old courtyard home. Built by a wealthy
silk-trading ancestor, the house has seen better days. In the main room,
now used for storage, a naked bulb illuminated diamond-shaped mosaics of
green and white tile, framing recessed antique shelves with foliated
arches. But the raw logs propping up the ceiling were a more recent
addition, installed after construction work by her neighbors caused long
cracks in the room’s walls.

Officials offered to help finance repairs but refused to replicate the
original craftsmanship. “If it was rebuilt, all the beautiful history
would be lost,” she said. Eventually they decided to leave the house in
its current condition as a draw for tourists.

Kashgar has been viewed as the jewel of Uighur civilization for centuries,
a center of trade and Islamic learning on the caravan routes linking
Europe and Persia with China. Marco Polo visited in the 13th century.
Today, it is the westernmost sizable city in China, near the borders with
Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan, Afghanistan, Pakistan and India. Beijing gave it
the privileged status of a Special Economic Zone in 2010 in the hope that
a flood of investment and infrastructure projects would help quell
political instability.

But ethnic tensions in Xinjiang have increasingly boiled over into
violence, most notably in deadly riots in Urumqi, the regional capital, in
2009. Clashes over the past year have claimed more than 100 lives, many of
them Uighurs killed by security forces during what officials describe as
terrorist attacks. Uighur exile groups put the blame for the bloodshed on
paramilitary police officers they say have been given the green light to
use deadly force against unarmed protesters.

The first sign that the strife was metastasizing beyond Xinjiang appeared
in October, when a vehicle carrying three Uighurs fatally plowed into two
pedestrians near Tiananmen Square in Beijing and wounded 40 others before
bursting into flames. The Chinese authorities said the attack was the work
of the East Turkestan Islamic Movement, a militant Uighur group.

In Kashgar, security forces standing guard with guns and shields are a
familiar sight. They are particularly visible in People’s Square, which is
dominated by a statue of Mao waving toward the Han area of the city; his
back is to the demolished Uighur quarter.

What remains of the Old City is rapidly being turned into an ethnic theme
park, with a $5 admission charge. The Beijing Zhongkun Investment Group
has leased the area from the neighborhood Communist Party committee and is
marketing it as a “living Uighur folk museum.”

According to Xu Lin, vice president of the company’s Kashgar branch, 20
households have signed contracts to open up their homes for tourists,
earning around $8,300 annually from the sale of food and trinkets. “Now
every family wants to join,” Ms. Xu said. She added that the company hoped
the Old City might one day be designated a World Heritage site by Unesco.

Those hopes, though, have crumbled along with the old houses. Beatrice
Kaldun, Unesco’s cultural specialist in Beijing, called the redevelopment
of Kashgar “one of the black spots of heritage conservation.”

Recalling a mission to Kashgar in 2009 to meet officials and inspect the
government’s construction plans, Ms. Kaldun said she was shocked by the
scale of destruction. “It was like a desert in the city,” she said. Though
she made delicate diplomatic requests that the authorities respect local
people and building customs, Chinese officials used her trip in a
propaganda campaign to imply that Unesco had endorsed the redevelopment.

Ms. Kaldun rejected that assertion. She likened the razing of the Old City
to the Taliban’s demolition of the huge sixth-century Buddha statues in
Bamian, Afghanistan, in 2001, saying it was too late to save either one.
“Nothing can stop this train anymore.”