[Heb-NACO] Roger's Summary of decisions , Editorial meeting Number 11, November 18, 2022

[Kohn, Roger]

ACQUISITIONS AND BIBLIOGRAPHIC ACCESS DIRECTORATE
POLICY, TRAINING, AND COOPERATIVE PROGRAMS DIVISION

SUMMARY OF DECISIONS, EDITORIAL MEETING NUMBER 9

November 18, 2022



               This Summary of Decisions will be posted on LC's website and may be accessed at https://urldefense.com/v3/__http://www.loc.gov/aba/pcc/saco/cpsoed/cpsoeditorial.html__;!!KGKeukY!2nTxvGH8DDXUntdp7zOvnIM9LweTlEfNQ-hkXoXLA5HQI90IjeRsO9q_5K5dlnG9uvZK-RP7hdykf0ns_tEWqWM-QJHQ0w$ .


SUBJECT HEADINGS

...

Formation of the Talmud

The work being cataloged encompasses two headings that can be formed using free-floating subdivisions, Talmud-History and Talmud-Publication and distribution. The proposal was unnecessary.

....

Graphic novels-Religious aspects; Graphic novels-Religious aspects-Judaism

The subdivision Religious aspects is usually used to indicate that the topic plays some role in the practice of the religion see H 1998. It is suggested that the cataloger consider the heading Judaism in comics. The proposal was unnecessary.

...

Judaism and comics

SHM H 310, sec. 1, says, "Establish new headings in the form [ Topic A ] and [ Topic B ] only when the work being cataloged discusses the relationship between the topics from both perspectives and in such broad terms that it could not accurately be described by the use of a main heading and subdivision." The work being cataloged discusses the impact Judaism has on comics but not the way that comics influence Judaism. The proposal was unnecessary.

Judeo-Iraqi language

The proposal makes it appear as if the cataloger is presenting this as a dead language. Some further research should be done because it appears as if there are still speakers of this language. The proposal may be resubmitted.

...

Virtue-Religious aspects-Judaism

The subheading religious aspects applies only to headings with no religious implications. Other works on virtue in other religions has the post-coordinated headings. It is suggested that the cataloger use the headings Virtue and Jewish ethics. The proposal was unnecessary.

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.osu.edu/pipermail/heb-naco/attachments/20230227/8c616f1f/attachment.html>